Description
Instructions
For this assignment, you will examine the data collection instruments used in two peer-reviewed articles on a technology topic and present the findings. Address all components for each article before moving on to the next article.
Your paper should include the following:
A discussion of the purpose of the instrument.
An overview indicating how the instrument was assessed for reliability (e.g., internal reliability analysis) and validity (e.g., confirmatory factor analysis).
An assessment of the strengths of the instrument.
An assessment of the limitations of the instrument.
Recommendations for improvements to the instrument.
Length: 5-7 pages, not including title and reference pages
References: Include a minimum of 5 scholarly resources
Unformatted Attachment Preview
sensors
Review
Trends in Single-Molecule Total Internal Reflection
Fluorescence Imaging and Their Biological Applications with
Lab-on-a-Chip Technology
Louis Colson 1 , Youngeun Kwon 2 , Soobin Nam 2 , Avinashi Bhandari 1 , Nolberto Martinez Maya 1 ,
Ying Lu 1 and Yongmin Cho 2, *
1
2
*
Department of Systems Biology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115, USA;
[email protected] (L.C.); [email protected] (A.B.);
[email protected] (N.M.M.); [email protected] (Y.L.)
Department of Chemical Engineering, Myongji University, Yongin 17058, Republic of Korea;
[email protected] (Y.K.); [email protected] (S.N.)
Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +82-31-330-6385
Abstract: Single-molecule imaging technologies, especially those based on fluorescence, have been developed to probe both the equilibrium and dynamic properties of biomolecules at the single-molecular
and quantitative levels. In this review, we provide an overview of the state-of-the-art advancements
in single-molecule fluorescence imaging techniques. We systematically explore the advanced implementations of in vitro single-molecule imaging techniques using total internal reflection fluorescence
(TIRF) microscopy, which is widely accessible. This includes discussions on sample preparation,
passivation techniques, data collection and analysis, and biological applications. Furthermore, we
delve into the compatibility of microfluidic technology for single-molecule fluorescence imaging,
highlighting its potential benefits and challenges. Finally, we summarize the current challenges and
prospects of fluorescence-based single-molecule imaging techniques, paving the way for further
advancements in this rapidly evolving field.
Citation: Colson, L.; Kwon, Y.; Nam,
Keywords: single-molecule imaging; TIRF; fluorescence; data analysis; microfluidics
S.; Bhandari, A.; Maya, N.M.; Lu, Y.;
Cho, Y. Trends in Single-Molecule
Total Internal Reflection Fluorescence
Imaging and Their Biological
Applications with Lab-on-a-Chip
Technology. Sensors 2023, 23, 7691.
https://doi.org/10.3390/
s23187691
Academic Editor: Sellamuthu Anbu
Received: 21 July 2023
Revised: 1 September 2023
Accepted: 3 September 2023
Published: 6 September 2023
Copyright: © 2023 by the authors.
Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland.
This article is an open access article
distributed under the terms and
conditions of the Creative Commons
Attribution (CC BY) license (https://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/
4.0/).
1. Introduction
Imaging techniques provide powerful tools to visualize and quantify molecular interactions, cellular dynamics, and tissue architecture and are therefore instrumental in advancing
our understanding of biological systems [1–12]. Certain imaging techniques can directly
observe individual biomolecules such as oligonucleotides, proteins, and protein complexes.
These single-molecule imaging techniques can provide information on the heterogeneity of the
system which can often be difficult to determine using other methods. In recent years, singlemolecule imaging with total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) has gained significant
popularity due to its accessibility and high sensitivity in probing the properties of biomolecules.
By enabling the visualization and tracking of individual molecules in exceptional spatial and
temporal resolutions, TIRF-based single-molecule imaging has opened up new avenues for
studying complex biological processes, including protein folding, protein–protein interactions,
DNA replication, and cellular signaling [13–22].
In this review, we specifically explore in vitro single-molecule imaging with
TIRF [11,23–25]. In addition to discussing the technical aspects of single-molecule imaging,
this review surveys and highlights several exemplary applications of TIRF-based singlemolecule imaging, especially microfluidic-based approaches. By showcasing the diversity of
biological questions addressed using this technique, we aim to demonstrate its broad impact
across various fields, including molecular biology, biophysics, and nanotechnology. Finally, we
address the potential prospects and challenges of fluorescence-based single-molecule imaging
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691. https://doi.org/10.3390/s23187691
https://www.mdpi.com/journal/sensors
Sensors 2023, 23, x FOR PEER REVIEW
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691
2 of 19
impact across various fields, including molecular biology, biophysics, and nanotechnology. Finally, we address the potential prospects and challenges of fluorescence-based sin2 of 20
gle-molecule imaging techniques. We also discuss the limitations and potential sources of
artifacts in single-molecule imaging experiments, as well as strategies to mitigate these
issues.
techniques. We also discuss the limitations and potential sources of artifacts in single-molecule
as well as strategies
to mitigate these
issues.
2.imaging
Optical experiments,
Systems for Single-Molecule
Fluorescence
Imaging
Fluorescence
single-molecule
imagingFluorescence
techniques rely
on the utilization of optical ra2. Optical
Systems
for Single-Molecule
Imaging
diationFluorescence
to probe individual
molecules
within
a
liquid
or
solid
sample.
To achieve
single-molecule imaging techniques rely on the
utilization
of opticalsuccessradiation
ful
single-molecule
imaging,
two
key
requirements
must
be
met:
(1)
ensuring
that resoto probe individual molecules within a liquid or solid sample. To achieve successful
singlenant
molecules
are
spatially
resolved
by
the
detector,
and
(2)
providing
a
sufficient
signalmolecule imaging, two key requirements must be met: (1) ensuring that resonant molecules are
to-noise
ratio
(SNR)by
forthe
the
single-molecule
signal within
a reasonable
averaging
time
[22].for
spatially
resolved
detector,
and (2) providing
a sufficient
signal-to-noise
ratio
(SNR)
Consequently,
a
fundamental
prerequisite
for
conducting
single-molecule
observations
is
the single-molecule signal within a reasonable averaging time [22]. Consequently, a fundamental
toprerequisite
dilute the concentration
of
the
target
molecule
of
interest
to
exceedingly
low
levels
(typfor conducting single-molecule observations is to dilute the concentration of the
ically
100 nM).ofThe
detection
of singlelow
molecules
via fluorescence-based
methods
detarget< molecule
interest
to exceedingly
levels (typically
< 100 nM). The detection
of single
mands
careful
optimization of the
signal-to-noise
signal
requires
molecules
via fluorescence-based
methods
demands ratio.
carefulMaximizing
optimizationthe
of the
signal-to-noise
the
selection
of an impurity
the highest
fluorescence
quantum
efratio.
Maximizing
the signalmolecule
requires with
the selection
of anpossible
impurity
molecule with
the highest
ficiency.
possible fluorescence quantum efficiency.
This
Thisapproach
approachharnesses
harnessesrecent
recentadvancements
advancementsininfluorescence
fluorescenceimaging
imagingtechniques,
techniques,
including
TIRF
microscopy
[23–25],
super-resolution
microscopy,
and
single-molecule
lo-loincluding TIRF microscopy [23–25], super-resolution microscopy, and single-molecule
calization
microscopy,
calizationmicroscopy
microscopy[26–32].
[26–32].TIRF
TIRF
microscopy,one
oneofofthe
themost
mostcommonly
commonlyemployed
employed
tools
principle of
of total
totalinterintoolsininsingle-molecule
single-moleculefluorescence
fluorescencemicroscopy,
microscopy, capitalizes
capitalizes on the principle
ternal
reflection.This
Thisphenomenon
phenomenon occurs when aa laser
nal reflection.
laserbeam
beamstrikes
strikesthe
theinterface
interfacebetween
between
a amedium
with
a higher
refractive
index
(typically
glass)
andand
a medium
withwith
a lower
remedium
with
a higher
refractive
index
(typically
glass)
a medium
a lower
fractive
index
(such
as
a
sample
solution)
at
an
angle
greater
than
the
critical
angle
(Figure
refractive index (such as a sample solution) at an angle greater than the critical angle
1A).
As a 1A).
result,
evanescent
wave is generated,
which excites
fluorophores
in the im-in
(Figure
Asan
a result,
an evanescent
wave is generated,
which
excites fluorophores
the immediate
vicinity
of the interface,
facilitating
the visualization
of single molecules
mediate
vicinity of
the interface,
facilitating
the visualization
of single molecules
near the
near the
sampleTIRF
surface.
TIRF microscopy
is practically
implemented
using
either a
sample
surface.
microscopy
is practically
implemented
by using by
either
a quartz
quartz
or the microscope
to the
generate
the evanescent
field and illuminate
prism
or prism
the microscope
objective objective
to generate
evanescent
field and illuminate
surfacesurface-immobilized
(Figure
1B). TIRF microscopy
offers exceptional
optical
immobilized
moleculesmolecules
(Figure 1B).
TIRF microscopy
offers exceptional
optical sectioning
sectioning
and
background
suppression,
leading
to
a
high
signal-to-noise
ratio.
and background suppression, leading to a high signal-to-noise ratio.
Figure
1. 1.
TIRF
microscopy
for for
single-molecule
fluorescence
imaging.
(A) Principle
of TIRF
Figure
TIRF
microscopy
single-molecule
fluorescence
imaging.
(A) Principle
of microsTIRF micopy.
(B)
Types
of
TIRF
microscopy:
prism-type
(P-TIRF)
or
objective-type
(O-TIRF).
croscopy. (B) Types of TIRF microscopy: prism-type (P-TIRF) or objective-type (O-TIRF).
Theevanescent
evanescent
field
intensity,I(z),
I(z),atata aperpendicular
perpendiculardistance
distancez zfrom
fromthe
theinterface
interfaceisis
The
field
intensity,
describedbybyEquation
Equation(1).
(1).
described
z
I (z ) == I ( 00
(1)
) exp
exp − d), ,
(1)
λ0
2
2 −1/2
d == n 21 sin
(2)(2)
θ − n 2 ) / ,,
4π
4
where I (0) represents the evanescent field intensity at the interface (Figure 1A). The characwhere 0 represents the evanescent field intensity at the interface (Figure 1A). The charteristic penetration depth (Equation (2)), d, is determined by the wavelength of incident
acteristic penetration depth (Equation (2)), d, is determined by the wavelength of incident
light ( λ0 ), refractive index of the medium through which the light initially passes (n1 ) and
in contact with the sample (n2 ), and incident angle (θ ). Typically ranging between 30 and
200 nm, the penetration depth defines the region within which fluorophores are effectively
excited by the evanescent wave.
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691
light ( , refractive index of the medium through which the light initially passes ( ) and
in contact with the sample ( ), and incident angle . Typically ranging between 30 and
200 nm, the penetration depth defines the region within which fluorophores are effectively
3 of 20
excited by the evanescent wave.
In addition, the detection of individual fluorophores is a critical aspect of single-molecule fluorescence imaging. Here, the numerical aperture (NA) is one of the key parameIn addition,
the detection
of individual
is acollection
critical aspect
of singleters. High
NA objectives
are commonly
used to fluorophores
maximize light
and detection
moleculeThe
fluorescence
Here,on
thethe
numerical
aperture
is oneresolution
of the key
efficiency.
specific NAimaging.
value depends
imaging setup
and (NA)
the desired
parameters.
NA objectives
are commonlyfluorescence
used to maximize
light
collection
and
and
sensitivity.High
For conventional
single-molecule
imaging,
objectives
with
detection
efficiency.
The
specific
NA
value
depends
on
the
imaging
setup
and
the
desired
NA values ranging from 1.2 to 1.49 are frequently employed. These objectives offer a balresolution
sensitivity.
For conventional
single-molecule
fluorescence
imaging,
ance
betweenand
high
light collection
efficiency and
reasonable working
distances.
They objecare
tives
with
NA
values
ranging
from
1.2
to
1.49
are
frequently
employed.
These
objectives
suitable for imaging samples in various configurations, including liquid solutions,
solid
offer a balance
between
high light collection efficiency and reasonable working distances.
surfaces,
and biological
specimens.
They
are
suitable
for
imaging
samples
in various
configurations,
including
liquid solutions,
The choice of camera is another
important
factor
in the detection
of individual
fluorsolid
surfaces,
and
biological
specimens.
ophores. Ultimately, digital cameras capture the photons from individual fluorescent molThe convert
choice ofthe
camera
is another
important
in the detection
of individual fluecules and
light into
electrical
signals. factor
The cameras
used for single-molecule
orophores.
Ultimately,
digital
cameras
capture
the
photons
from
individual
fluorescent
TIRF imaging tend to have quantum efficiencies above 80%, spectral range between
300
molecules and convert the light into electrical signals. The cameras used for single-molecule
and 1100 nm, low readout noise, and millisecond readout speeds [33]. Electron multiplyTIRF imaging tend to have quantum efficiencies above 80%, spectral range between
ing charge coupled devices (EMCCDs) and the scientific complementary metal–oxide–
300 and 1100 nm, low readout noise, and millisecond readout speeds [33]. Electron multisemiconductor (sCMOS) devices are the most common types of cameras used in singleplying charge coupled devices (EMCCDs) and the scientific complementary metal–oxide–
molecule imaging. Note that most of the biological applications discussed in Section 5 use
semiconductor (sCMOS) devices are the most common types of cameras used in singlean EMCCD camera. Some recent laboratory advances in imaging technology may further
molecule imaging. Note that most of the biological applications discussed in Section 5 use
improve the performance of scientific cameras across the broadband spectrum [34–36].
an EMCCD camera. Some recent laboratory advances in imaging technology may further
improve the performance of scientific cameras across the broadband spectrum [34–36].
3. Sample Preparation
Sample Preparation
preparation is a critical step in single-molecule imaging of biological mole3. Sample
cules for
repeatable
and reliable
results.
section, we define
“sample
preparation”
Sample preparation
is a critical
stepIn
inthis
single-molecule
imaging
of biological
molecules
asfor
therepeatable
preparation
of
the
imaging
device
(Figure
2)
and
any
labeling
of
the
biological
and reliable results. In this section, we define “sample preparation”molas the
ecules.
Generally,
biomolecules
non-specifically
adhere
to the surfaces
of the imaging
depreparation
of the
imaging device
(Figure 2) and
any labeling
of the biological
molecules.
vice.
Thus,
the
preparation
of
the
imaging
device
includes
a
passivation
step
to
reduce
Generally, biomolecules non-specifically adhere to the surfaces of the imaging device. Thus,
non-specific
binding
andimaging
false-positive
Fluorophores
provide
readoutnon-specific
for interthe preparation
of the
devicesignals.
includes
a passivation
step toa reduce
actions
between
molecules or
the functions
of theprovide
reaction
system.for
Preparing
biological
binding
and false-positive
signals.
Fluorophores
a readout
interactions
between
molecules
for
the
experiments
includes
a
labeling
step
to
conjugate
fluorophores
to
molecules or the functions of the reaction system. Preparing biological moleculesmolefor the
cules
of interestincludes
and a strategy
to constrain
the location
of the molecules
of interest
in the
experiments
a labeling
step to conjugate
fluorophores
to molecules
of interest
and
imaging
region
[37,38]. the
There
are methods
that detect
freely diffusing
singleregion
molecules
a strategy
to constrain
location
of the molecules
of interest
in the imaging
[37,38].
[39,40],
this review,
we limit
ourdiffusing
scope to single
single-molecule
with
immobiThere but
are in
methods
that detect
freely
moleculesstrategies
[39,40], but
in this
review,
lized
molecules.
we limit
our scope to single-molecule strategies with immobilized molecules.
Figure
Schematic
representation
imaging
device.
The
construction
imaging
device
Figure
2. 2.
Schematic
representation
of of
anan
imaging
device.
The
construction
of of
anan
imaging
device
entails
integration
a microscope
a coverslip,
employing
double-sided
tape
entails
thethe
integration
of aofmicroscope
slideslide
and aand
coverslip,
employing
double-sided
tape for
pre-for
cision
juxtaposition,
followed
by hermetic
sealingsealing
with epoxy
resin. The
holes
the slide
areslide
usedare
precision
juxtaposition,
followed
by hermetic
with epoxy
resin.
Theon
holes
on the
as used
the inlet
and
outlet
solution
exchange.
as the
inlet
andfor
outlet
for solution
exchange.
3.1.
Surface
Passivation
3.1.
Surface
Passivation
Established
passivation
techniques
prepare
imaging
device
rely
coating
Established
passivation
techniques
to to
prepare
thethe
imaging
device
rely
ononcoating
chemically
treated
glass
surfaces
with
biocompatible
reagents
such
as
polyethylene
glycol
chemically treated glass surfaces with biocompatible reagents such as polyethylene glycol
(PEG), phospholipids, or Tween-20. In this section, we briefly describe the PEG, lipids, and
Tween-20 passivation methods. These methods produce similar results and are described in
depth elsewhere [41–43]. The PEG passivation method relies on the amino-silanization of
the glass surface. Usually, researchers use KOH to form alcohol groups on the glass surface.
Amino silane can react with these alcohol groups on the surface. This reaction (shown in
Figure 3A) takes the following form: ROH + (OCH3 )3 SiOCH3 → CH3 OH. To complete
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691
(PEG), phospholipids, or Tween-20. In this section, we briefly describe the PEG, lipids,
and Tween-20 passivation methods. These methods produce similar results and are described in depth elsewhere [41–43]. The PEG passivation method relies on the amino-si4 ofon
20
lanization of the glass surface. Usually, researchers use KOH to form alcohol groups
the glass surface. Amino silane can react with these alcohol groups on the surface. This
reaction (shown in Figure 3A) takes the following form: + →
the
commercially
availablecommercially
PEG ester molecules
silane groups
passivation,
. To complete
the passivation,
availablereact
PEGwith
esterthe
molecules
react
(Figure
to PEGylate
the surface
ofPEGylate
the coverslip
[41]. This
passivation
method
with the3B)
silane
groups (Figure
3B) to
the surface
of covalent
the coverslip
[41]. This
covacan
protein
denaturing
conditions
as 8 M conditions
guanidinium
chloride
lent withstand
passivationharsh
method
can withstand
harsh
proteinsuch
denaturing
such
as 8 M
(GdmCl)
[44] and
4M urea
[45]. For
dichlorodimethylsilane
guanidinium
chloride
(GdmCl)
[44] the
andTween-20
4M urea passivation,
[45]. For theaTween-20
passivation, a
(DDS)-treated
glass surface
forms a hydrophobic
coating
can be passivated
the
dichlorodimethylsilane
(DDS)-treated
glass surface
forms that
a hydrophobic
coatingwith
that can
addition
of
the
biocompatible
surfactant
Tween-20
[42].
For
the
passivation
with
phosphobe passivated with the addition of the biocompatible surfactant Tween-20 [42]. For the
lipids,
glasswith
devices
can be incubated
with liposomes
to form awith
fluid
lipid bilayer.
Thea
passivation
phospholipids,
glass devices
can be incubated
liposomes
to form
liposomes
for passivation
in single-molecule
TIRF experiments
have been
made
from
fluid lipid used
bilayer.
The liposomes
used for passivation
in single-molecule
TIRF
experilipids
1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine
(DOPC) and egg phosphatidylments such
haveasbeen
made from lipids such as 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine
choline
[46,47].
(DOPC) and egg phosphatidylcholine [46,47].
Figure 3. Chemical diagrams of surface preparation steps. (A) Diagram of amino silanization of
Figure 3. Chemical diagrams of surface preparation steps. (A) Diagram of amino silanization of
glass surface. (B) Diagram of PEG-ylation step with heterobifunctional biotin–PEG–succinimidyl
glass surface. (B) Diagram of PEG-ylation step with heterobifunctional biotin–PEG–succinimidyl
carbonate (SC) ester. (C) Diagram of the interactions between avidin and biotin.
carbonate (SC) ester. (C) Diagram of the interactions between avidin and biotin.
3.2. Surface
3.2.
Surface Functionalization
Functionalization
Typically,
surface-immobilized
avidin,
streptavidin,
neutravidin
(from
here
on avTypically, surface-immobilized
avidin,
streptavidin,
or or
neutravidin
(from
here
on avidin
idin
will
be
used
interchangeably
with
any
of
these
forms
of
avidin)
tether
biotinylated
will be used interchangeably with any of these forms of avidin) tether biotinylated biomolecules
biomolecules
the imaging
region. To
immobilize
avidinbiotins
on the are
surface,
biotinsonto
are the
into
the imagingtoregion.
To immobilize
avidin
on the surface,
introduced
troduced
ontoor
the
surface
or during
step. Formethod,
the PEGapassivation
surface
before
during
thebefore
passivation
step. the
Forpassivation
the PEG passivation
percentage
method,
a molecules
percentagethat
of passivate
the PEG molecules
passivate
surface
contain
a biotin
of
the PEG
the surfacethat
contain
a biotinthe
moiety
on the
opposite
end
moiety
on
the
opposite
end
from
the
ester
group
[43].
The
ester
group
in
the
biotinylated
from the ester group [43]. The ester group in the biotinylated PEG molecule reacts with the
PEG molecule
with the
on the
shown inpassivation
Figure 3B.method,
For the
amine
group onreacts
the surface
as amine
showngroup
in Figure
3B.surface
For theas
Tween-20
Tween-20 passivation
method, researchers
introduce
to the imaging
researchers
introduce biotinylated
BSA to the
imagingbiotinylated
device priorBSA
to passivation.
Thedebivice prior BSA
to passivation.
Thehydrophobic
biotinylatedsurface
BSA adheres
to the hydrophobic
surface
before
otinylated
adheres to the
before Tween-20
passivates the
surface
[42].
Tween-20
passivates
the surface
Forathe
lipid of
passivation
either a fraction
of
For
the lipid
passivation
method,[42].
either
fraction
the lipidsmethod,
will be biotinylated
[46] or
avidin
willwill
be directly
applied to
theorimaging
surface
before passivation
Avidin binds
to
the lipids
be biotinylated
[46]
avidin will
be directly
applied to [47].
the imaging
surface
−15 M) [48]. This affinity comes from a number
biotin
with
high
affinity
(KD~10
of
beforemolecules
passivation
[47].
Avidin
binds
to biotin
molecules with high affinity (KD~10−15 M)
hydrogen
formed
aminoof
acids
of avidin’s
biotin-binding
site andthe
theamino
biotin
[48]. This bonds
affinity
comesbetween
from a the
number
hydrogen
bonds
formed between
molecule
as diagramed
in Figure 3C.
avidin
forms
a tetramer,
avidin molecules
bound
acids of avidin’s
biotin-binding
site Since
and the
biotin
molecule
as diagramed
in Figure
3C.
to
the avidin
biotins forms
on the aimaging
surface
still
contain available
bindingonsites
immobilize
Since
tetramer,
avidin
molecules
bound tobiotin
the biotins
theto
imaging
surbiotinylated
molecules.
face still contain
available biotin binding sites to immobilize biotinylated molecules.
3.3.
Protein Biotinylation
3.3. Protein
Biotinylation
One
strategy
One strategy to
to directly
directly biotinylate
biotinylate proteins
proteins of
of interest
interest involves
involves introducing
introducing an
an
AviTag
[49–51].
The
BirA
ligase
recognizes
the
15
amino
acid
AviTag
and
conjugates
AviTag [49–51]. The BirA ligase recognizes the 15 amino acid AviTag and conjugates
biotin
biotin
the tag’s
lysine
residue
[52,53].
BirA
biotinylationoccurs
occursthrough
throughaa two-step
two-step
to the totag’s
only only
lysine
residue
[52,53].
BirA
biotinylation
reaction where biotin first reacts with ATP before the amine group of AviTag’s lysine
residue attacks the ester in biotin (Figure 4C). Overexpressing BirA ligase can biotinylate
the protein in vivo [53] or purified BirA can biotinylate the protein in an in vitro reaction
system [53,54]. Other direct coupling methods include using biotinylated peptides [55] or
ligating a biotinylated peptide to the C-terminus of a protein of interest [14]. Biotinylated
peptides or molecules with a high affinity to fusion tags can also be used to introduce
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691
reaction where biotin first reacts with ATP before the amine group of AviTag’s lysine residue attacks the ester in biotin (Figure 4C). Overexpressing BirA ligase can biotinylate the
protein in vivo [53] or purified BirA can biotinylate the protein in an in vitro reaction sys5 of 20
tem [53,54]. Other direct coupling methods include using biotinylated peptides [55] or
ligating a biotinylated peptide to the C-terminus of a protein of interest [14]. Biotinylated
peptides or molecules with a high affinity to fusion tags can also be used to introduce
biotin
proteins of
of interest
interest[56].
[56].Biotinylated
Biotinylatedantibodies
antibodies
[57,58]
biotinylated
nubiotin to
to the
the proteins
[57,58]
oror
biotinylated
nuclecleotide
oligos
[59–61]
can
indirectly
couple
proteins
to
the
surface.
Tethering
the
sample
otide oligos [59–61] can indirectly couple proteins to the surface. Tethering the sample to
to
imaging
surface
does
require
high
efficiency.
majority
of unbiotinythethe
imaging
surface
does
notnot
require
high
efficiency.
TheThe
vastvast
majority
of unbiotinylated
lated
molecules
will
not
stick
to
the
passivated
surface
and
at
saturating
conditions,
most
molecules will not stick to the passivated surface and at saturating conditions, most biotinbiotin-binding
sites
will
bind
to
biotinylated
biomolecules.
binding sites will bind to biotinylated biomolecules.
Figure4.4.Chemical
Chemicaldiagrams
diagramsof
ofcommon
commonprotein
proteinlabeling
labelingstrategies.
strategies.(A)
(A)Thiol–maleimide
Thiol–maleimidereaction
reaction
Figure
represents
a
common
way
to
label
cysteine
residues
in
proteins.
(B)
NHS
ester
reaction
with
lysine
represents a common way to label cysteine residues in proteins. (B) NHS ester reaction with lysine
provides a way to label proteins. (C) The process of AviTag biotinylation as a way to tether proteins
provides a way to label proteins. (C) The process of AviTag biotinylation as a way to tether proteins
to immobilized avidin.
to immobilized avidin.
3.4. Protein
ProteinFluorescence
FluorescenceLabeling
Labeling
3.4.
The requirements
requirements for
for fluorescent
fluorescent labeling
labeling are
are more
more stringent.
stringent. One
One of
of the
the most
most comcomThe
mon
strategies
conjugates
fluorescent
molecules
with
maleimide
groups
onto
the
thiol
mon strategies conjugates fluorescent molecules with maleimide groups onto the thiol
groupson
onthe
thecysteines
cysteinesof
ofproteins
proteins(Figure
(Figure4A).
4A).This
Thisstrategy
strategyworks
worksbest
bestfor
forsmall
small proteins
proteins
groups
withoutessential
essentialcysteine
cysteine residues.
residues. Similarly,
Similarly, lysine
lysine can
can react
reactwith
withNHS
NHSester
estergroups
groupson
on
without
fluorophores(Figure
(Figure4B).
4B).Recent
Recentstudies
studiesalso
alsouse
useunnatural
unnaturalamino
amino acids
acids to
toperform
perform click
click
fluorophores
chemistrywith
withfluorophores
fluorophores[54,62].
[54,62].This
Thismethod
methodworks
workswell
wellfor
for large
large proteins
proteinsor
orprotein
protein
chemistry
complexesand
andfor
forproteins
proteinsthat
thatharbor
harbor
essential
cysteine
residues.
Additionally,
decomplexes
essential
cysteine
residues.
Additionally,
thethe
development
of high-affinity
protein
fusion
tags allows
N- orNC-terminal
fusionfusion
tags totags
provide
a
velopment
of high-affinity
protein
fusion
tags allows
or C-terminal
to prospecific
and simple
way toway
bindtoa bind
fluorophore
to the target
of interest
[63]. Fluorescently
vide a specific
and simple
a fluorophore
to the target
of interest
[63]. Fluoreslabeled
antibodies
offer a potential
alternative
to these aforementioned
methods. For
all of
cently labeled
antibodies
offer a potential
alternative
to these aforementioned
methods.
these,
of fluorophores
and the labeling
strategy
will
depend
on depend
the biological
For allthe
of choice
these, the
choice of fluorophores
and the
labeling
strategy
will
on the
application. Roy et al. [33] provide a practical overview of the TIRF-based single-molecule
experiments with Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET).
Sensors 2023, 23, x FOR PEER REVIEW
Sensors 2023, 23, 7691
6 of 19
6 of
20
biological application. Roy et al. [33] provide a practical overview of the TIRF-based
single-molecule experiments with Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET).
4. Analysis Methods
4.
Single-molecule data often exhibit
exhibit inherent
inherent noise
noise stemming
stemming from
from both
both the
the system
system
Single-molecule
under study
study and
and the
the measurement
measurement instrument.
instrument. This noise can manifest in various forms,
under
including sample
sample stage
stage drift
drift [64,65],
[64,65], Gaussian
Gaussian fluctuations
fluctuations [66,67], non-Gaussian
non-Gaussian variaincluding
tions[68–70],
[68–70],diffusive
diffusivebehavior
behavior
[71,72],
and
even
undefined
sources
[73,74].
Complications
[71,72],
and
even
undefined
sources
[73,74].
Complications
tionsparticularly
arise particularly
when
the nature
of the underlying
fluctuation
is unknown,
it
arise
when the
nature
of the underlying
fluctuation
is unknown,
as it canas
potentially
follow follow
either aeither
Gaussian
or non-Gaussian
distribution.
Consequently,
extracting
can potentially
a Gaussian
or non-Gaussian
distribution.
Consequently,
exmeaningful
information
from single-molecule
data poses
significant
challenges.
In this
tracting meaningful
information
from single-molecule
data
poses significant
challenges.
section,
we willwe
introduce
key steps
insteps
the analysis
with key
examples
(Figure (Figure
5).
In this section,
will introduce
key
in the analysis
with
key examples
5).
Figure 5. Workflow of single-molecule imaging data analysis.
Figure 5. Workflow of single-molecule imaging data analysis.
4.1. Point Spread Function Fitting
4.1. Point
Spread high
Function
Fitting
To achieve
spatial
resolution, it is essential to precisely localize the position
Todetected
achieve high
spatial resolution,
it is essential
to precisely
localize
thea position
of
of each
fluorophore.
This localization
is typically
performed
using
technique
called
point spread
function This
(PSF)localization
fitting, where
the observed
intensity
distribution
of a
each detected
fluorophore.
is typically
performed
using
a technique
fluorophore
fit to afunction
mathematical
the PSF.
accurately
determining
the center
called pointisspread
(PSF) model
fitting,ofwhere
theBy
observed
intensity
distribution
of a
of
the
PSF,
the
position
of
the
fluorophore
can
be
determined
with
sub-pixel
precision,
fluorophore is fit to a mathematical model of the PSF. By accurately determining the center
enabling
precise
localization
of single
molecules.
et al. [29] comprehensively
of the PSF,
the position
of the
fluorophore
canSage
be determined
with sub-pixel evaluated
precision,
software
for single-molecule
localizationSage
microscopy
Many modules
enabling packages
precise localization
of single molecules.
et al. [29](SMLM).
comprehensively
evalufrom
these software
packages
would be usable
for TIRF-based
single-molecule
ated software
packages
for single-molecule
localization
microscopy
(SMLM).fluorescence
Many modimaging
ules fromdatasets.
these software packages would be usable for TIRF-based single-molecule fluorescence imaging datasets.
4.2. Extracting Information from Signal
Among the
most prevalent
types of single-molecule imaging data are time series
4.2. Extracting
Information
from Signal
signals
characterized
values ranging
zero to an upper
limit.data
To extract
desired
Among
the mostby
prevalent
types offrom
single-molecule
imaging
are timethe
series
siginformation,
several
techniques
have
been
developed
to
fit
the
noisy
time
series
data to
nals characterized by values ranging from zero to an upper limit. To extract the desired
an idealized model involving discrete steps and dwell times [73]. One widely employed
information, several techniques have been developed to fit the noisy time series data to an
method is hidden Markov modeling (HMM) [75–79]. HMM enables the identification of
idealized model involving discrete steps and dwell times [73]. One widely employed
hidden (unobservable) states within a Markovian process, where the present and future
method is hidden Markov modeling (HMM) [75–79]. HMM enables the identification of
states depend solely on the current state, independent of the system’s prior states. The
hidden (unobservable) states within a Markovian process, where the present and future
idealized model